Operations

Logistics and distribution

How operations consulting lifted a freight carrier’s margin from 4.1% to 11.6%

Client

Regional freight carrier

1,900 people, 11 terminals in the Southeast

Partner

Helen Marsh

Start

February 2025

Length

30 weeks

Team

1 partner, 1 principal, 3 consultants

Operating margin

14 months after Week 0

4.1%

to

11.6%

Operating margin went from 4.1% to 11.6% in the 14 months that followed.
Operating margin went from 4.1% to 11.6% in the 14 months that followed.
Semi trucks lined up at a freight terminal at dawn

The situation

The carrier had grown by winning contract freight, and every new contract made the network busier and the margin thinner. Revenue had grown for two years. Operating margin had sat near 4% for six months, which left almost nothing for trucks, drivers or a bad winter.

The leadership team knew some lanes lost money. They did not know which ones, because fuel, empty miles and terminal labor were spread evenly across every customer in the reports. The board had asked for a plan by the spring.

What we did

Helen Marsh and the team spent the first four weeks in the terminals and the dispatch room, starting with Memphis. We rebuilt the cost of every lane from the trip records: miles loaded and empty, hours at each dock, fuel and tolls. Finance checked each number against the monthly accounts.

The model showed 37 lanes priced below what they cost to run. A handful of large customers made up most of the loss. We took the numbers to each of those customers with the sales team, and repriced or exited the lanes that could not be fixed.

In parallel, dispatch and the terminal managers redesigned how loads were matched to trucks, so fewer trucks came home empty. Each terminal got a daily stand-up and a board on the wall with three numbers.

Semi truck hauling a plain white trailer on a highway in autumn for a regional freight carrier

The weeks that moved the number

The turn

Weeks 1 to 4
Cost of every lane rebuilt from trip records, 37 lanes found below cost.

Weeks 5 to 8
New pricing taken to the largest loss-making customers with the sales team.

Weeks 9 to 14
Load matching changed in dispatch. Empty miles start to fall by Week 12.

Weeks 15 to 24
Daily stand-ups running at all 11 terminals. Overtime falls as dock hours even out.

Weeks 25 to 30
Routines and the lane model handed to the carrier’s own finance and operations teams.

Results

Operating margin

4.1%

to

11.6%

Empty miles

19% to 11%

Lanes priced below cost

37 to 4

How we measured

Client finance team, monthly management accounts. Fuel surcharge and spot rate changes removed using the client’s lane index.

Lane repricing +3.9 pts, empty miles +2.2 pts, terminal labor +1.4 pts.

They put a partner in our Memphis yard from the first week. By the summer we were making money on lanes we had planned to drop.

Chief executive, regional freight carrier

References from these clients are available after a first call.

Hand-over

The lane model now sits with the carrier’s finance team, who reprice every contract against it before renewal. The terminal stand-ups run without us. We checked in each quarter for a year. Margin dipped in the winter, as it always had, and passed 11% by spring.

Lead partner

Helen Marsh

Start with a brief

Tell us the number you want to move.

Send a short brief. A partner reads it the same day and replies within one business day.

Stack of clipped case documents and reading glasses on a wooden desk after a consulting engagement

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.