Ask a finance team for margin by product and you will have it by lunch. Ask for margin by customer, after the cost of serving each one, and you will usually get a long pause. In most mid-market companies that number has never been calculated.
It matters because customers who buy the same products can cost very different amounts to serve. One orders full trucks once a week. Another orders a few cases every day, asks for special labels, pays in 75 days and calls customer service twice a week. On the product margin report they look the same.
What goes into the report
A useful cost-to-serve report does not need a new system. It needs a year of order data and an honest allocation of the costs that sit below gross margin. We usually start with five:
Order handling: how many orders and order lines each customer places
Delivery: miles, drops, waiting time and any special freight
Warehouse: picks, special packing and returns
Service: calls, claims and account management time
Cash: days to pay, multiplied by your cost of money
Each cost is spread across customers by the activity that drives it. Order handling follows the number of order lines. Delivery follows miles and stops. Finance should agree every driver before anyone looks at the results, so nobody argues with the method once the results are in.
What it usually shows
In the work we have done across distribution, logistics and manufacturing, the pattern repeats. Roughly a fifth of customers earn more than all of the profit. A middle group roughly breaks even. A final group loses money once the full cost is counted, and it often includes some of the largest names on the list.
At one regional freight carrier, the lane-level version of this report found 37 lanes priced below cost. Most of the loss came from a handful of large contract customers. The reports spread fuel, empty miles and dock labor evenly across every load, so the loss never showed.
What to do with it
Most loss-making accounts can be kept. A conversation about how they order usually fixes them. Minimum order sizes, delivery windows, a charge for rush orders and payment terms that match the work usually close most of the gap.
Take the numbers to the customer with your sales team. Show them what their ordering pattern costs and offer two or three ways to change it. Many customers have no idea their habits are expensive, and some are glad to order less often for a better price.
A few accounts will not change. For those, raise the price to cover the cost or agree a date to part ways. Either way, the decision is made with numbers on the table.
Keep it running
A cost-to-serve report run once is a project. Run every quarter, it becomes the way sales and finance agree prices. The companies that keep the margin they gain are the ones that check every new contract against the model before they sign it.

Start with a brief
Bring us the question behind the note.
Send a short brief. A partner reads it the same day and replies within one business day.




